Electric insert vs gas insert — which is better for an existing fireplace?
At nearly 2,650 feet, Waynesville tilts hard toward gas — with a heating season about three weeks longer than Asheville's and nights running 10 to 15 degrees colder, a main room needs the 70-percent-plus heat of a sealed gas insert, not the roughly 5,000 BTU an electric unit supplies. Electric stays a supplemental choice for a small, already-comfortable space.
The math changes when it is this cold
Waynesville asks more of a fireplace than the lower valleys do. Those older Hazelwood homes were built around drafty open fireboxes that lose more heat up the flue than they put out, and at 2,644 feet the cold arrives early and stays late. A gas insert — a Napoleon Oakville X4 at 20,000 BTU or a Kozy Heat Chaska 25L at 25,000 with its blower — is a sealed heater sized to actually hold a living room through a mountain-winter evening. An electric insert's roughly 5,000 BTU, about 1,500 watts for 400 square feet, is real coziness in a bedroom but not a heating plan for the main room in this town's longer, harder season.
Fuel and permits up here
Waynesville runs mixed — natural gas reaches parts of town, while homes out toward the coves are on propane, which burns hotter per unit and needs its own orifices and pressures dialed in. Either way the gas insert is licensed work: liner, fuel connection, a Haywood County permit, and the inspector. Electric just slides in and plugs in. One more thing worth weighing at 35 minutes from our Asheville showroom — a gas insert wants an annual tune-up before the season, while an electric unit is close to maintenance-free. For a house that leans on its hearth this hard, gas is usually still the call. Free assessment: (828) 545-0525.
Fireplace help in Waynesville
We install and service fireplaces throughout Waynesville and the rest of Haywood County — just 35 minutes west from our Asheville-area showroom.
Related questions
- Wood-to-gas vs wood-to-electric conversion — which is better for my fireplace?
- Electric fireplace insert vs electric log set — which should I put in my old fireplace?
- Does an electric fireplace put out as much heat as a gas fireplace?
- Which is cheaper to run, a gas fireplace or an electric fireplace?
- Which fireplace still works during a power outage — gas, wood, or electric?